Whisky Reviews

Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.

Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.

Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Antique Blends Trio

Charlie picks up three blends from the past - his own past - and dips in to see what he was missing. A Chivas Regal 12yo from the 1970s alongside an old Johnnie Walker Swing and a 1980s Teachers.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Official vs Indy: Glenlossie

A stranger to Glenlossie until 2025, Charlie uncovered one of Diageo’s ‘blend houses’ in a Cadenhead’s tasting. Typically for him, a pleasant experience and a bottle purchase finds him exploring and comparing.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop

Shieldaig Oloroso Cask

Archie happens upon a ‘distillery’ he’s never heard of. This ‘Shieldaig’ turns out to be a branded malt, which is fine. It has a purpose. Just like Dramface, which he also wants to discuss a little.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Broddy Balfour Scotch Whisky Broddy Balfour

Bowmore 15yo New vs Old

After being challenged with a blind pour, Broddy gives the much misaligned Bowmore 15yo another chance. After gaining a reputation of being poorly handled in official bottles, this could be a rare uptick.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Wally Macaulay Scotch Whisky Wally Macaulay

Strathisla 40yo

Wally finally cracks open a bottle that’s been around for so long it became a burden of anxiety. Now that it’s open; how’s he feeling about having a 40yo Strathisla on the shelf?

Read More
Scotch Whisky Mason Mack Scotch Whisky Mason Mack

Highland Park 18yo

Who would’ve thought some dog-sitting would result in the ability to explore a bottle of whisky that you’d never buy yourself? Mason digs into this vintage Highland Park 18yo.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Dalmore 18yo

The plastic stag of Dalmore 18yo is in the crosshairs as Charlie revisits an old friend, one from a time before he was sullied by ‘informed’ opinions, community ‘consensus’ and, well, possibly much better whiskies.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Bowmore Trio

Charlie asks the all important question - If Bowmore is truly one of Scotch whisky’s legends - why are none of their official releases any good? Brutal. But he explores three to find out.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Broddy Balfour Scotch Whisky Broddy Balfour

Knockando 12yo 1991

Nostalgia remains very much part of whisky enjoyment long-term. In this review of a 1991 official Knockando, Broddy shares his own take on whisky nostalgia, while using a handy bell-curve to send it home.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Dougie Crystal Scotch Whisky Dougie Crystal

Table Whisky

A man struck by strong branding and potent design, Dougie spots something that isn’t whisky - as he knows it. But it is £32.50, so he fires in to explore Port of Leith’s ‘Table Whisky’.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Fergus Mackay Scotch Whisky Fergus Mackay

Dalwhinnie 15yo

Nostalgic about his formative whisky days exploring supermarkets, Fergus arrives at the official 15yo Dalwhinnie. As a geek today, while he appreciates its value, we know where he goes from there…

Read More
Scotch Whisky Calder Dune Scotch Whisky Calder Dune

Killara Port Cask

After a horrific experience with Tasmanian whisky, Calder returns to his local stuff after significant inspiration from his favourite dram pairing; literature. He sets out with a Killara Port Cask.

Read More