Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Hawaiian Bourbon Duo
Broddy recommends everyone gives in to holiday whisky-souvenir purchases, as he reaches for a summer pour that instantly transports him back in time to family fun in Hawaii.
Caol Ila 8yo Tawny Port
In his debut piece, we get to know Kenzie a little through his quieter pursuits; walking on rainy days and meeting others who enjoy the same. In his flask today is a Tawny Port Cask Caol Ila from Murray McDavid.
Ardnahoe 6yo Chairmanβs Selection
Due to recent fortunes, Archie has struggled to breathe. His work needs attention and whisky has suffered. It takes something as big and punchy as this Ardnahoe Chairmanβs Selection to bring him up for air.
Clydeside 8yo Small Batch Oloroso
After travelling with a only few select picks, Charlie quickly became frustrated that he didnβt have his usual selection. He realises he needs the thrill of choice. Clydesideβs brand new 8yo in the glass. Wally joins in too.
Laphroaig 15yo 2026
Earie lost an old flame, 25 years ago he fell for Laphroaig, only for things to inevitable change. Now, with this newly envisioned 15yo, can he renew the spark?
Official vs Indy: Aberfeldy
Vanilla. Some distilleries are just a bit like that. Charlie continues his Official vs Indy series with Aberfeldy and struggles to define what itβs all about. A Decadent Drinks is up against an official 21yo Madeira cask.
Glasgow 1770 8yo Peated Bourbon Cask
Mason isnβt a cat-lover. Nor, it seems, is he ready to be seduced by this young Glasgow 1770 8yo Peated. Maybe, however, with a little time, anyoneβs mind can be changed.
Cadenheadβs Warehouse Tasting Blended Malt 17yo
Charlie falls in love with a blended malt. One that he loves so much heβs even tried to make a version of his own at home. With this Cadenheadβs Warehouse special, heβs wondering whatβs in the char.
Benromach 12yo
Wally yearns for the 1990s. He thinks whisky was better and living was easier. But there are some glimmers of hope for our futures, in whisky at least. He counts this new Benromach 12yo as one of them.
Thompson Bros Mystery Malt Series 6 x2
This time around itβs Charlieβs turn to armour up and attempt a game of whisky guesswork. Itβs the Thompson Brothersβ Mystery Malts Series 6 in the glass this time - two of them. How does our Chic do?
Anohka Alberta Single Malt - Costco Exclusive
Despite being a fan of some of his local distilleries, Broddy missed the appearance of an official Alberta Whisky Act. Not slow to cash-in, Costco got together with some distilleries - including this tasty Anohka.
Ruadh Mhor (Glenturret) 11yo
Earie is eager to slip into whisky season. Happily, a birthday gift seems to be the perfect fit to assist in bringing the orange and red-tinged seasonal vibes. This time, itβs a peated Glenturret - Ruadh Mhor - from North Star.
Official vs Indy: Balvenie
Continuing his series, this time Charlie visits Balvenie. While the outcome might be - for us - expected, it lights his interest in yet another distillate that is usually otherwise obscured from us. A bonus from Kininvie appears too.
Jacktonβs RAER Inaugural
Looking back on a plethora of inaugural bottlings from all these new distilleries in recent years has Gilbert realising itβs hard to keep up. This time itβs Jacktonβs turn with their RAER Inaugural.
Adelphi Summer 2026 Outturn
When times are tougher and the purse strings are pulled tighter on the whisky budget, Drummond is pleased to benefit a little from the Dramface Deflection System. Six from Adelphi in the hopper today!
Holyrood Pitch
After following in whiskyβs footsteps for many years, Fergus is shocked when he stumbles over some early-days tasting notes. Heβs come a long way, but is he up to Holyroodβs Pitch?
Ardbeg 15yo Trudernish
Ardbeg seems to be doing things in a fair way these days, or is Wally just being his usual, far-too-generous, optimistic self? Heβs got the 15yo Trudernish in the glass and he seems to like it.
Glenrothes - Official vs Indy
In Charlieβs distillery deep-dives and comparisons, the indies have always won out. However, could a naturally coloured official Glenrothes turn that around? He tries two of them alongside two Cadenheadβs releases..
Ardnamurchan Warehouse Release Cask 107
Toothache is a terrible thing at the best of times, but when youβre living on a remote island with no immediate care, Doog learns just how tough it can be. Can a magical Ardnamurchan help?
NcβNean Huntress Duo
Ogilvie leads as he, Archie and Eallair team up on a duo of special releases from NcβNean. Supplied through Nick, each of them have a go at Edition 4 β Lemon Meadowβ and 5 βMalted Teacakeβ.