Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Hawaiian Bourbon Duo
Broddy recommends everyone gives in to holiday whisky-souvenir purchases, as he reaches for a summer pour that instantly transports him back in time to family fun in Hawaii.
Ardnamurchan Warehouse Release Cask 107
Toothache is a terrible thing at the best of times, but when youβre living on a remote island with no immediate care, Doog learns just how tough it can be. Can a magical Ardnamurchan help?
White Peak Wire Works Duo
Murdo knows what to look out for while travelling. Some of the things heβs really keen to try just donβt make it to his native Hong Kong. Like these Wire Works souvenirs he grabbed from The Whisky Exchange.
Eagle Rare 10yo
Mason has been β enjoyingβ his recent hiatus from alcohol. This year has been longer than most due to Europeβs βheat domeβ of 2026, which has had him reach for this Eagle Rare 10yo upon return.
Thompson Brothers Mystery Malt x2
Itβs Wallyβs turn to tackle a brace of the formidable Thompson Brothers Mystery Malt Series 6. As usual, he dives in completely blind, but this time heβs confident. Is it misplaced?
Jack Danielβs Single Barrel Barrel Proof
Once in a store, Ogilvie heartily recommended this Jack Daniels Barrel Proof to an acquaintance. When he returns to a bottle three years later, he realises some things change, if fact sometimes everything does.
Glen Garioch 12
Dougie discovers, for the first time, brown noise. He shares his thoughts. He also discovers, for the second time, Glen Garioch 12yo. He also shares his thoughts. And his photos? We hope youβre sitting down.
Leopold Bros 8yo
Sad he no longer travels the US like he once did, Fletch is grateful once more for the sharing and caring of the whisky community. Especially the mules. A Leopold 8yo bourbon in the glass.
Penelope Wheated Bourbon
Through chasing whatever whiskies he can explore, Ogilvie notices a lost-in-translation scenario between bourbon and malt. He wonders why this lauded Penelope Wheated is so⦠simple.
Decadent Drinks December 2025
Itβs Dougieβs turn to step up with a box of the latest outturn from Decadent Drinks. Like this weekend deep-dive read, itβs no small undertaking. But it starts with an Ardnamurchan, so heβs inβ¦
North British 34yo
Doogβs love for an Edinburgh single grain knows no bounds, especially when he can follow a story and reconnect with an old pal. Unkilteredβs 34yo North British in the glass.
Ardnamurchan Quartet
Covering four Ardnamurchans in one sitting, Dougie eventually discovers something heβs been searching for in whisky - that mysterious βeffervescenceβ. Perfect that it comes from his beloved Ardna.
Uncle Nearest 1856 100ΒΊ Proof
Our cocktail shenanigans continue, but not without reviewing the whisky itself first. Ainsley brings us a Claret Snap, his own take on the Whisky Sour, using the acclaimed Uncle Nearest 100ΒΊ Proof.
Woven Homemade
Dougie needs to bump an order for free shipping and is drawn to a reasonably priced Woven Homemade Blend, which causes him to reflect on how his perspectives have altered immeasurably since the dark days.
Finglassie & Ardnamurchan 6yo
Dougie returns from recent distractions to grab two seemingly unrelated - at first - malts for a Misty Isle twofer: A Thompson Bros Ardnamurchan & an Inchdairnie Finglassie from Lady of the Glen.
Holladay Soft Red Wheat
Ogilvie has a problem; heβs running out of variety. With a βmereβ 34 bottles he feels the need to fortify things. He discovers a bottled-in-bond Holladay Wheated Bourbon...
Old Forester 1910
Some days are tougher than others; even for a suit in a courtroom. Our resident lawyer sits with his concerned neighbour after a tough day and leans on a generous Old Forester 1910 for his catharsis.
SMWS Skooshy Stroopwafel
Howβs your Friday? Fancy a vivid trip to the west coast of Scotland on a moonlit night? Doog, literally, takes you there. With a nice SMWS single malt too.
North British 15yo & 34yo
Dougie scoffs a Fragrant Drops North British bottle-split but immediately orders a follow-up bottle and compares it to a 34yo counterpart. He likes, and the prices are remarkable.
Ardnamurchan AD/10
In reflective mode, Dougie does what we need him to do: close out the year with a retrospective via Ardnamurchan. AD/10, Sauternes and AD/Venturers all up for grabs. He pulls in Ainsley to help out.