Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Benromach 12yo
Wally yearns for the 1990s. He thinks whisky was better and living was easier. But there are some glimmers of hope for our futures, in whisky at least. He counts this new Benromach 12yo as one of them.
Adelphi Summer 2026 Outturn
When times are tougher and the purse strings are pulled tighter on the whisky budget, Drummond is pleased to benefit a little from the Dramface Deflection System. Six from Adelphi in the hopper today!
Fragrant Drops Duo
North America hosts the World Cup and the USA finds itself once more distracted by this odd sport that fascinates the rest of planet Earth. CA based Archie drinks it all in with two recent bottles from Fragrant Drops.
Mortlach 11yo Signatory 100ΒΊ Proof
Sometimes, we donβt get exactly what we expect. Thatβs when an open mind and patience can deliver a decent experience regardless, as Earie and Fergie discover on this Signatory Mortlach.
Official vs Indy: The Singletons
Charlie continues his deep dive into new distilleries (to him), this time uncovering the two βGlensβ of Ord and βDullan, then comparing two Special releases to indies from James Eadie and the Thompson Bros.
Edradour No.2 Inaugural 7yo
We all hit forks in lifeβs road. Archie shares one of his. Eventually decisions lead us to other, unplanned opportunities. Like when a bottle he was chasing escaped and made him pick up a peach of an Edradour.
Ardnahoe Cask Strength
Reading this would make you consider we have a recruitment academy. We donβt, but itβs nice to see enthusiastic learning, such as both Dramface & Ardnahoe Cask Strength inspiring our Archie.
Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 8yo
In discovering a cracking SMWS Loch Lomond Inchmurrin, Broddy goes full Broddy and gives us a deep dive into our scoring, the whys and the whats and the hows. Itβs fascinating.
Glenlivet 2007 10yo
Is it snobbery to suggest cask-driven flavour isnβt desirable? Or to mention that some whiskies are βengineeredβ? Fergus tracks down a Signatory Glenlivet that is a no-holds-barred unapologetic sherry bomb.
Thompson Bros Private Stock 8yo
Refining his whisky-sights, a measured gamble on the ever-reliable Thompson Brothers connects Tav with a βteaspoonedβ bottle heβd have to pay double for to grab the branded version.
SMWS Rhosdhu 8yo (Loch Lomond)
Joining SMWS requires a membership which, as well as some other IB vagaries, was intimidating to Hamish. Now he wholeheartedly embraces indies but he shares why, until now, heβs never signed up.
Glen Scotia Trio
Innes gets giddy while visiting the hidden gem that is Glen Scotia. Full of the distillery-visit-glow, he snags two single casks to compare with a favourite at home, wondering why itβs still βhiddenβ.
Glenlivet 12yo 200th Anniversary
Curiosity gets the better of Fletch. With Glenlivet marking 200 years, theyβve released a 12yo that looks identical to the standard. Only available through TWE, he dives in to compare the worldβs best selling malt.