Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Port Askaig Cask Strength
A team review is required around a new take on Elixirβs Port Askaig series and their first Cask Strength Small Batch. Wally leads with a deep dive into why weβre not drinking enough. Apparently.
Millstone 7 yo PX & 3 yo Peated PX
In something of a follow up to Earieβs Shelter Point piece, we hear about Broddyβs visit to what may be his desert island distillery -The Netherlandβs Zuidam, makers of Millstone. Dougie chimes in too.
Rock Island Trio
A sudden gust of luck brings a random Instagram win for Earie. In enjoying a Christmas selection set of Douglas Laingβs Rock Island malts, he finds a way to share his splash of good fortune with us all.
Shelter Point 10yo
Worlds collide as an in-real-life cross border meet up and distillery visit has otherwise unobtanium whisky change hands and call for for a three-way Dramface review, this time Batch 3 of Shelter Pointβs 10 year old Canadian malt.
Benromach Bourdeaux 12yo
Drummond dives into another solid Benromach, this time in the Contrasts Series range with their Double Matured Bordeaux. With it, he reaffirms that age isn't everything and even though it is not quite a hole-in-one, its still a worthy addition to the Benromach shelf.
Loch Lomond βAqvavitaeβ 10yo
Amazing gestures of generosity place Doog in the possession of two much celebrated special releases from Loch Lomond; the XL Fermentation DE3 goes up against Aqvavitaeβs 2022 release.
DrΓ m MΓ²r: A Selection of 2023
Earie takes a wander through the Dram MΓ²r Autumn/Winter releases 2023 and discovers a solid turnout, but one of them knocks him clean off his feet.
Glenlivet 12yo Double Oak
Glenlivetβs ubiquitous 12yo in its slightly more modern βDouble Oakβ guise is gifted to Ogilvie as he departs for his newly relocated life. Exhaustion has him skip the bottle specs, forcing a blind sip and a surprise.
North British 29 Year Old
It seems weβve discovered the next rabbit hole that threatens to swallow our Doog for a while - that of Single Grain. Old, decadent, tasty and fairly priced stuff too.
Glen Garioch - 11yo Independents
As part of a βteam building exerciseβ Hamish is invited to stretch his olfactory senses in a structured test. His colleagues - knowing heβs a whisky reviewer - determine that heβll βboss itβ. Well, did he? You know the answerβ¦dontcha?
NcβNean Single Malts Duo
In a Dramface first, we visit NcβNean. Two malts showcasing what theyβre up to in sustainability and organic processes. Ramsay wonders if heβs missed anything, with a little help from Drummond.
Loch Lomond Distillery Edition 4
Malt? Or grain? Wally tries to decipher the latest release form Loch Lomondβs fascinatingly geeky Distillery Edition series, which isnβt quite as easy as it at first may seem.
Ballindalloch Trio
A rare visit to Dramface towers from Dallas, as he shares his thoughts on Ballindalloch. Itβs a story heβs followed from the start. He compares three of their releases to others who choose to move perhaps a little too early.
Ardnamurchan Rum Cask Release
A buddy-up review is required as Drummond and Dougie both have their beloved Ardna from rum casks to discuss. This wide but limited release is no doubt on a few Santa lists this year.
Port Charlotte 10 vs Laphroaig 10
After rekindling his love of scotch Eallair decides to put all the βnaturalβ and βintegrityβ mantra to test. He selects what may be the two most obvious examples to sip side by side; Laphroaigβs ubiquitous 10yo and the popular Port Charlotte 10. This Friday First is not to be missed.
Lot 40 Cask Strength 11yo & 12yo
Enjoying your booze this week? This has been handled gently but itβs no less hard hitting. For some, perhaps not easy to read. As you hear about two legendary Canadian bottlings, awareness is crucial.
Ledaig Rioja Cask Versus
Earie places a popular bang-for-buck Ledaig against a very similarly profiled indie release, only to have him wondering why there isnβt an official cask strength from Mullβs in vogue peat monster.
Glenallachieβs Meikle TΓ²ir Trio
With so many whiskies being released itβs hard to keep up. Wally spends an entire article making excuses while admitting to the new normal; solid, reliable, tasty whiskies. Predictable but reassuring, like these new Glenallachie Meikle TΓ²ir releases.
SMWS Dark βnβ Stormy CrΓ¨me BrΓ»lΓ©e
Dougie is caught trolling the dying embers of the auctions once more for bargains. Whatβs this heβs found? A very curious SMWS oddball he needs to decipher first, both in description and flavour. We suspect heβs hit the rye wall once more.
Johnnie Walker Black Label 12yo
A self-administered humility check is required as Ogilvie is disappointed to receive an old standard. As he digs in to the Johnnie Walker Black, heβs reflective of the easy rise of snobbery in whisky.