Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Glen Scotia Campbeltown Festival 2024
As the 2024 Campbeltown Malts Festival 2024 draws near, Ramsay and Drummond buddy up for a popular modern malt, fairly priced and tasty, they celebrate βthe good old daysβ of right now.
Watt Whisky Spring 2024 Outturn
Ramsay and Fergus buddy up for a wander through the most recent outturn from Watt Whisky. Exploring a grain, a blend, two malts and a Guyana rum, they actually find some consensus!
Ardnahoe 5yo Inaugural
Another new release has landed, this time a are thing indeed: a brand new Islay. Loaded with anticipation, Wally digs in to Ardnahoe - the latest peat-bomb to blow up the whisky scene.
Balblair 15yo vs Balblair 2000
Like a band that has sold out, Fergus felt abandoned by his favourite distillery. He took a long time to give Balblair another chance. But here it is. A head-to-head. Rebrand vs previous livery.
Strathearn Inaugural 2024
Very much enjoying the new release from Strathearn, Wally reflects upon the producers and stewards in scotch whisky who actually care about the product and its legacy.
Glenturret Triple Wood
Upon discovering this bottle received a near-perfect 99 points at the IWSC, Nick dives in to see what all the fuss was about. You know what he discovered, donβt you?
Bakerβs 7
In a breakaway move, the Dramface Colonials conspire at their water cooler, setting up their own splinter cell. Happily, it results in a virtual sipping session and collaborative review of this Bakerβs 7 Bourbon.
Edinburgh International Festival Blend 2023
Ainsley wonders three things as he sips the 2023 Festival Blend from J&A Mitchell: is 2024 finally the year of the blend?, isnβt grain whisky basically vodka?, and why are people paying Β£180 for a cheap sipper?
Craigellachie 17yo SMWS 44.148
Itβs about addiction, but not the addiction youβre thinking of. Murdo shares some confessions as he reviews an SMWS Craigellachie 17yo. Some of us might find this difficult reading.
Millstone 2012 Founders Reserve
In order to stave off the dreaded malt-fatigue and keep things fresh and exciting, Earie has found the perfect strategy, and a banger of a whisky too; Millstoneβs Rye 10yo.
Two Brewers Release 36
In typical Dramface style, Aengus and Broddy team up on a bottle split review to asses the winner of the Toronto Whisky Societyβs blind panel competition; a Two Brewers Moscatel Release 36
Ardnamurchan Golden Promise
The say distance makes the heart go fonder. Dougie returns to Ardnamurchanβs fair whisky shores after a long break and discovers whatβs inside this 5 year old Unpeated Golden Promise Barley expression.
InchDairnie Pitkevy
After finding nothing on the television, Fergus finds nothing in the Whisky Shop. But heβs one of us, so he leaves with 5 bottles including a brand new InchDairnie exclusive. He seems pleased.
Glenburgie 2011 10yo
We all like intensity and focus, but what about when we just need something functional to βget it doneβ? Drummond makes the case for an under-the-radar CΓ rn MΓ²r bottling of Glenburgie he stole at auction.
Macallan A Night on Earth in Scotland
After some early encouragement into the whisky scene via friends and Macallan, Murdo persists with a bottle of the Night on Earth Seasonal Release, only to discover itβs a stinker.
Around the World with TBWC
In an effort to keep his palate and whisky fun as diverse as possible, Broddy tucks into some That-Boutiquey-Whisky-Company releases from Europe, including Austria, Switzerland Sweden and Finland.
Shortcross Malt & Pot Still Duo
Faced with a sea of repetitive, dull, expensive and uninspired Irish whiskey releases, a frustrated Hamish searches for a spark of inspiration to celebrate St Patrickβs and beyond.
Benromach Peat Smoke Bourbon vs Sherry
A collab is required as Broddy and Drummond both review what we believe to be some of the best value all-natural whiskies about right now. Benromach Peat smoke time.
Ben Nevis 9yo Bloodtubs
On a trapse to the Big Smoke to explore some whisky in his favourite bar, Doog catches the lurgy. But not before he discovers a belter of a Ben Nevis form Woodrows - and the concept of a bloodtub.
Heaven Hill 7yo
Another cracking Ogilvie tale of whiskey folks from the South, and a little bottled-in-bond bourbon edyacashun woven in. Heaven Hillβs 7yo Kentucky Straight in the glass.