Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Ben Nevis Trio
In trying to understand why Ben Nevis is such a βconnoisseurβs maltβ Ainsley assembles a trio of indies and pours them alongside each other for a cosy night hiding from the Parisian rain.
Campbeltown Journey vs Loch
For those of us living in the wider Scotch Whisky diaspora, we often must experience Campbeltownβs mythical spirits vicariously through others. In Ogilvieβs latest, he tracks down two of the Wee Toonβs Blended Malts in this side by side comparison.
Lochlea Fallow Edition
After some epiphany moments sipping Lochlea with pals, Hamish charges out to buy a bottle, only to ponder whether itβs the whisky or the company that makes the best whisky memories.
Turntable Paradise Funk
Our Dramface debutant today shares his passion for music with an appropriate release form Turntable; their malt-heavy and affordable Paradise Funk. Itβs Fergusβ call as to whether itβs killer, filler or grower.
Talisker X Parley Wilder Seas
Sharing some things about the Isle of Skye that are both expected and unexpected, Dougie Crystal finds parallels in a glass of his, thus far ignored, local libation: Talisker.
Springbank 13yo Local Barley
Knowing itβs pretty difficult to get a Springbank Local Barley, Wally goes ahead with a review anyway; to share his theories, but also just to say thanks.
Travel Retail Exclusive Quartet
When we love whisky so much, itβs hard to be brutal about some of the obvious negatives. Yet sometimes, when things are clearly wrong, we just have to call it out. This decision was not taken lightly.
Old Forester 1920 - Prohibition Style
Finally snagging himself an Old Forester 1920, Hamish wonders why there arenβt more nods to the past in todayβs whisky making excitement. As he ponders, he dives into his Glencairn time machine and skips back 100 years to US Prohibition time.
Glenturret Triple Wood
Excited by whisky exploration, Paisley loves a distillery visit. In the bling of Glenturretβs swanky new VC, she picks up the Triple Wood. But how does it fare back in her less-glitzy Glasgow flat?
Benriach 21yo
A vintage Benriach soothes Fletch as he protests the fleecing of travellers at visitor centres across Scotland, with the story of The Pilgrim. Many of us can relate.
Gouden Carolus Madeira
The last thing Earie needs is more fuel for FOMO, but this time heβs on home turf. Itβs different. Yet, instead of a biased review, what we actually read from this coming-of-age story is a sense of relief.
Balvenie 21yo Portwood
Fletch is trying hard to find a nice, special occasion whisky but, in another fit of disappointment, heβs reminded instead of a childhood movie that still haunts him today.
Daftmill 2011
Logan succumbs to his life-long nemesis; FOMO. Having been tempted into sinking a Β£100 on a bottle of Daftmill, heβs left feeling a little underwhelmed and forced into learning yet another life-lesson.
Waterford All Smoke No Mirrors
Our resident Irishman Hamish takes a St Patrickβs Day tour through Waterfordβs Exploration Series peated tasting set, and finds enough of a surprise to think Irish peated is under-appreciated. βοΈ
Woodrowβs Pulteney 15yo
With a confession that he knows very little about art, Fletch considers the art of whisky over a lesser-spotted indie Pulteney 15yo, and how itβs not always about its creation.
Mannochmore 13yo
As he settles into life in Dixie, Ogilvie meets up with a formidable local gent who declares if it isnβt bourbon, it isnβt whiskey. A dinner is the prize if a mind can be changedβ¦
Glasgow 1770 Small Batch Duo
Dougie takes another look at Glasgow 1770 with two releases: their Unpeated Cognac Cask Finish and Manzanilla Sherry Cask Fully Matured. In them he finds how a few key decisions made well can swing the opinion of many.
Deanston 15yo Tequila Cask
Just because you can, doesnβt mean you should. Itβs one of Fletchβs favourites; Deanston. Looking for something that the Tequila cask has imparted, he compares it to a similarly insipid Tequila cask blend.
Aberfeldy 10yo Provenance
Dove-tailing Doogβs review of the mass-market Aberfeldy 12yo, Ainsley finds an all-too-rare alternative, one more tailored for those of a geeky bent. Inexpensive too!
Bruichladdich Laddie Ten
Logan reflects on 20 years of whisky love and barely recognises who itβs become. This 2013 Bruichladdich Laddie Ten however offers a glimmer of hope to rekindle whisky romance.