Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Spirit of Yorkshire 6yo Madeira
Doogβs annual sailing trips to Campbeltown with his sidekick Foosty have taken on different flavours of adventure every time. He shares part 1 at Cadenheadβs & a Spirit of Yorkshire that, in itself, takes him on a journey.
Glenmorangie 16yo The Tribute
Broddy spots a tall bottle with appealing specs; 16 years and all ex-bourbon. Heβs in. Glenmorangie too. Expecting an amplified 12yo, heβs left, not for the first time, rueing unmet expectations.
Ardnamurchan AD/
Itβs cocktail Friday - a whisky review and a personal cocktail recipe from one of the team. Gilbert kicks off with a trip to the coast and his take on the Old Fashioned, with a coastal Ardnamurchan AD/ as the base.
Golden Ribbon 1980s Blended Scotch
Were old blends better? Ainsley snags an old export blend and compares it to five contemporary scotch blends available to him in France. The results are revealing. It does not go well.
Dalmore 18yo
The plastic stag of Dalmore 18yo is in the crosshairs as Charlie revisits an old friend, one from a time before he was sullied by βinformedβ opinions, community βconsensusβ and, well, possibly much better whiskies.
Glen Moray 15yo 2007 BBR
In a fascinating piece, Aengus returns from his coffee obsession to apply some learnings to whisky. With a tasty Berry Bros Glen Moray in the glass, he tries to uncover what different water brings for flavour.
Caol Ila 10yo Adelphi
In another call for support of independent specialist retailers, Ainsley and Ramsay team up to celebrate a Caol Ila released by Adelphi to mark Arthur Motleyβs 20 years at Royal Mile Whiskies.
Bardstown Bottled-in-Bond
As close as we get to comedy; Ogilvie shares a nightmare dinner evening with a βwhiskeyβ theme. An event so traumatic, he needed the salve of this Bardstown Bottled-in-Bond to right himself once more.
Westport 15yo Good Spirits Co.
Charlie finds himself on an exploratory road to uncover teaspoon mysteries. With an immensely distracting Westport from Good Spirits Co. heβs transported to traversing Scotlandβs famous Bealach na BΓ .
Glasgow 1770 Constantia
A shipping miscommuniquΓ© sees various Dramface team members end up with whisky they didnβt expect. This time itβs Glasgowβs 1770 Constantia and it means three can join in on the review.
Bunnahabhain 12yo Vintage
Realising whiskyβs time capsule proposition while increasingly troubled by potential nostalgia, Ogilvie seeks out a vintage Bunnahabhain 12yo to see if the flavours of his memory can be matched.
North Star Campbeltown Connection 10yo
Charlie hops onboard for another circle around the whisky discovery track. This time, heβs recalling his six milestones as he journeys back into blends with a North Star Campbeltown creation.
Longrow Trio
With three Longrow expressions as company, and in a reflective mood, Drummond looks back on his first days living in Scotland as an ex-pat American. He remembers one of his influential coaches in Scottish life - and whisky.
Glengoyne 10yo
Faced with a bargain, Fletch returns to a bottle heβs not touched in years. Noticing just how much the prices of supermarket whiskies are being crunched, he picks up Glengoyneβs 10yo to consider why.
North British 15yo 100ΒΊ Proof
Over the years, Earie has taught himself what he likes and likes less. But with a dearth of Signatory Vintageβs 100ΒΊ Proof Series in Belgium, he picks up a North British 15yo grain, and learns a lesson.
Decadent Drinks May 2025 Outturn
Wally sets aside a day to sit with a line up of Decadent Drinks releases. He uncovers some show stoppers and - remarkably - he can even afford one of them.
Ardnamurchan The Midgie 2025
Introducing βMyrtleβ: 2025βs latest Ardnamurchan Midgie Release. This time using a few port casks, sheβs a charmer. Four of the team line up to introduce themselves. No repellent required.
Springbank 10yo Open Day 2025
Back for his tricky follow up piece, Felix snags himself a Springbank - a Malt Festival bottle no less. As he considers how easy this was to come by, he shares his thoughts on why. And neckpours! Wally chimes in too.
Glenlivet 2007 10yo
Is it snobbery to suggest cask-driven flavour isnβt desirable? Or to mention that some whiskies are βengineeredβ? Fergus tracks down a Signatory Glenlivet that is a no-holds-barred unapologetic sherry bomb.
Murray McDavid Strathdearn
Doog tops up an online order with something heβs never tried before, and this Murray McDavid Strathdearn (Tomatin) serendipitously opens up a conversation to reveal a βsecretβ about its presentation.