Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Linkwood 10yo Signatory
A self-declared lover of anything Linkwood, even Murdo has to admit that sometimes it is possible to find something you donβt enjoy - despite expecting to. Case in point - a 10yo Signatory Linkwood.
Bruichladdich 15yo Ferguson Whisky
In a short and punchy love letter to whisky and its shared moments of joy, Charlie offers up his find of 2025 - a Bruichladdich 15 year old from a bourbon barrel and a new indie - Ferguson Whisky.
Dunvilleβs Palo Cortado 10yo
Enjoying a cracking bottle of Dunvilleβs 10yo Palo Cortado has Hamish wondering why there isnβt more made of the rich whisky history in his homeland. Is it time for a Bushmills Belfast Experience?
Decadent Drinks September 2025 Outturn
Ogilvie senses impostor syndrome. But heβs made of strong stuff and plods on regardless, doing a great job of sharing his thoughts on the September outturn from Decadent Drams for us all.
Cadenheadβs Ledaig 14yo & WLP 2025
After a mini-gathering at Whisky Live Paris, Hughie and Ainsley buddy up for a short resumΓ© of events over a Cadenheadβs Ledaig 14yo, as well as a campaign for us all to join them in Paris in future.
Lochlea Dark Briar vs Fallow
Hamish is drawn to comparing Lochleaβs new Dark Briar to the similar sherry-cask Fallow Edition. In doing so he starts to wonder how the concept of a βcore rangeβ ever came about in malt whisky.
Cadenheadβs Glen Grant 21yo
Ainsley rejoices in the friends and like-minded companionship can bring, yet selects a special and mature Cadenheadβs Glen Grant to put forward the case for sipping, contemplatively, alone.
Clydeside Napier
Charlie is on the hunt for whiskies that can engage both the purist and the pragmatist, without costing the earth. He finds one and, as is often the case, it was on his door step. The Clydeside Napier.
Indri Agneya
Earie admits heβs become something of a fanboy of the oh-so-recently unheard of Piccadilly single malt releases. This time itβs a peated affair in the shape of the Indri Agneya.
Johnnie Walker Double Black
It takes a trip far away, with too little whisky, to make Charlie reflect on how lucky he is to live so close to the source. With a Johnnie Walker Double Black, he sees that Scotland is, actually, a great place.
North British 34yo
Doogβs love for an Edinburgh single grain knows no bounds, especially when he can follow a story and reconnect with an old pal. Unkilteredβs 34yo North British in the glass.
Springbank 14yo Bourbon Wood
As part of a recent fondness for both his Campbeltown faves and a penchant for auction hunting, Charlie snags a classic Springbank legend. But thereβs always a risk, isnβt there?
Highland Park Cask Strength
In order to admit you might have been wrong about something, you need humility - and time. A sample from the archive stash helps too. Broddy revisits an affordable and over-performing Highland Park.
Glen Scotia 14yo The Dragon
With knowledge of his locally produced Italian specialities, Hughie is skeptical when he picks up a discounted bottle of Glen Scotiaβs 14yo The Dragon - from Barolo casks. Was he right to be nervous?
Ardnamurchan Sauternes
Dougie has been out injured. All his own doing, of course. Heβs now medicating in a bath of Sauternes-flavoured Ardnamurchan. Four of them, actually. Heβs been missed.
Anohka This Is Not Whisky Cask #63
Given that Broddy is Canadian, living in Alberta, heβs remarkably quiet about Canadian whiskies. Unless itβs Anohka, heβs not quiet about this. And itβs not even whisky yet.
Dingle 10yo Single Malt
Hamish has been waiting patiently for this milestone. As a fan of the ethics & approach of Dingle, heβs finally been rewarded with a ten year old Irish Single Malt. Does he love it?
Glendronach 21yo
With a rare glimpse into Murdoβs home life, he shares a tale with a bottle that has become something of a domestic icon for him. A vintage Glendronach 21yo(?) from 2021.
Cadenheadβs Glenburgie 13yo
Fergie wonders about his whisky personality; is he a hoarder, a collector or a rabbit-holer? A gifted whisky map from his dad confirms the latter and this Cadenheadβs Glenburgie offers up another.
North British 33yo
In recent months Hamish has taken a step back from whisky and is viewing things from a little further back. As he returns to a 33yo bargain-banger from the Thompson Brothers, has he missed it?