Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Balblair Vintage Duo
Keeping special bottles for occasions that warrant them can become an unnecessary burden on the whisky. Fergus shares a moment where some precious vintage Balblair could be set free.
SV Speyside (M) 2011
Itβs not like our Doog to forget his decorum, but a new yearβs faux pas leaves him reeling with shame; has he become a whisky snob? He makes good with a Signatory 100 Proof Maybe-Macallan.
Glenrothes 8yo
Earie has a think about the annual Online Scotch Whisky Awards, premiumisation and why he can only enjoy a delicious Glenrothes through an indie.
Tullibardine Two Ways
Letβs hand this tease over to the author; βBut I reckon Iβve been blindsided by this βsingle caskβ truth and itβs making me wonder if anything is what it seems anymore.β Doog uncovers untruthsβ¦
Benromach First Fill Sherry
Seeing too many shiny things at once is too much for Wally. Visiting his favourite spot to buy too many whiskies, he snags a UK exclusive Benromach with the prettiest of hues, only to wish heβd stuck to his original mission.
Macallan 12yo Sherry Oak
Through sheer ambivalence, it has been years since a Macallan has appeared in Wallyβs stash. Now he considers how many more years before he buys another.
G&M Connoisseurβs Choice Quartet
Paying tribute to one of scotch whiskyβs original indie bottlers, the consistent Gordon & MacPhail, Broddy uncovers four bangers and attempts to explain why he thinks thatβs so easily possible.