Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Mossburn 12yo Foursquare Rum Cask
Dougie encounters a home intruder, only to discover at his new home on the Isle of Skye, itβs βthe done thingβ. And anyway, this intruder brings a surprise mystery bottle of Foursquare finished Blended Malt Whisky from Mossburn.
Glencadam 21yo
Saving a special bottle for a quiet moment, Ramsay swims in a dusty and now discontinued Glencadam 21yo while wondering if itβs worth reviewing hard-to-find bottles. We must Tav! We must!
Kilchoman USA Small Batch Release
A wiser-than-her-years daughter encourages Ogie to grab some whisky swag before heading to his new, state-controlled liquor, home. It proves fruitful as he bags himself a lesser-seen Kilchoman dusty.
Glencadam Reserva De Porto Tawny
Dougie battles from the Highlands to the Lowlands with nervy drives, fallen trees and slippery hills. Upon arrival heβs rewarded with a decent value Tawny Port Glencadam. Was it just rewards?
Millstone 100 Rye
Our resident Canadians, Aengus and Broddy, get together and get excited over a bottle split of rye whisky. Letβs just say they went Dutch.
Caol Ila 25yo
How can Wally admit to loving a bottle and yet score it 3/10? Itβs complex, but in this case he thinks Diageo have made it a big, confusing, opaque and cynical mess - for retailers and punters.
Compass Box KWM 30th Anniversary
Broddy heads back to grab a second bottle of an absolute banger, only to discover theyβre all sold. Worse, some naughty whisky mules have been smuggling βem out of his native home to punt on Scottish auction sites. Cue a Broddy huff.
Virginia Distilling Cider Cask Finish
On the hunt in a neighbouring state for some Springbank goodness, Ogilvie decides not to buy and switches to something completely different. I wonder if you can guess why?
Dougieβs 2023, in Review
While reviewing those two Aqvavitae Ardnamurchan bottles, somehow, in so many incidental ways, Dougie highlights all of the things to be grateful for exploring whisky. Those high-energy, emotional, glowing, amber-inspired moments we all love to live for.
Loch Lomond 14yo
Not just a review from Broddy, but a confession. A reflection on what heβs buying: how many, how much is open, what producers and - how much heβs actually spent. Sobering indeed.
Watt Whisky Outturn Winter 2023
Dramface takes on a six bottle outturn from Watt Whisky, itβs a team effort. Two single malts, a blended malt, a blend, a single grain and a curious Bas Armagnac. No wonder the images are blurry.
Linkwood Duo
Finding independent bottlers slightly intimidating at first, Hamish getβs hooked on Linkwood during a whisky trip and discovers indy Linkwoods online, at auction and everywhere.
Makerβs Mark KSBW
As we swing into boxing day, Doog finds an appropriate dram to utterly switch off with. The fact that he can pick it up for the equivalent of mere buttons, in whiskey terms, sweetens the already sweet deal.
Port Askaig Cask Strength
A team review is required around a new take on Elixirβs Port Askaig series and their first Cask Strength Small Batch. Wally leads with a deep dive into why weβre not drinking enough. Apparently.
Millstone 7 yo PX & 3 yo Peated PX
In something of a follow up to Earieβs Shelter Point piece, we hear about Broddyβs visit to what may be his desert island distillery -The Netherlandβs Zuidam, makers of Millstone. Dougie chimes in too.
Rock Island Trio
A sudden gust of luck brings a random Instagram win for Earie. In enjoying a Christmas selection set of Douglas Laingβs Rock Island malts, he finds a way to share his splash of good fortune with us all.
Shelter Point 10yo
Worlds collide as an in-real-life cross border meet up and distillery visit has otherwise unobtanium whisky change hands and call for for a three-way Dramface review, this time Batch 3 of Shelter Pointβs 10 year old Canadian malt.
Benromach Bourdeaux 12yo
Drummond dives into another solid Benromach, this time in the Contrasts Series range with their Double Matured Bordeaux. With it, he reaffirms that age isn't everything and even though it is not quite a hole-in-one, its still a worthy addition to the Benromach shelf.
Loch Lomond βAqvavitaeβ 10yo
Amazing gestures of generosity place Doog in the possession of two much celebrated special releases from Loch Lomond; the XL Fermentation DE3 goes up against Aqvavitaeβs 2022 release.
DrΓ m MΓ²r: A Selection of 2023
Earie takes a wander through the Dram MΓ²r Autumn/Winter releases 2023 and discovers a solid turnout, but one of them knocks him clean off his feet.