Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 8yo
In discovering a cracking SMWS Loch Lomond Inchmurrin, Broddy goes full Broddy and gives us a deep dive into our scoring, the whys and the whats and the hows. Itβs fascinating.
Glen Garioch 13yo Fragrant Drops
After Dougieβs whirlwind November, he finally has time to sit with his Fragrant Drops 13yo Glen Garioch. Since itβs rainy, he also uncorks his all-time Geery pinnacle bottle for a side-by-side.
Edradour 10yo 200th Anniversary
As a stickler for justice, Fletcher gives a shout out to the 200 years old Edradour. As he sips this new, all natural 10yo, he wonders what wouldβve happened if it hadnβt been saved.
Arran 18yo
Charlie has some agonising to do over his accumulated open bottles. He dives in to cull some off which, happily, brings this Arran 18yo to the fore, and he discovers itβs the first time weβve reviewed it.
Elevenses Linkwood 9yo
A solid and dependable dram is needed to help Mason come down after a whirlwind trip to Glasgow for the annual Whisky Festival. This Fragrant Drops Elevenses Linkwood does the trick nicely.
Living Souls Kildalton 19yo
Wally returns to ask why there are so many silly protectionist rules around stating where a whisky is made - and to whoβs detriment when itβs so. He does so over a rather lovely Living Souls 19yo βKildaltonβ.
Ardara Irish Single Malt 2025
Once in a while along comes a flavour profile that stretches our frame of reference in whisky enjoyment. Enter Hughie and his astonishment over a bottle of Ardara Irish Single Malt. Heβs intrigued.
Glasgow 1770 8yo Bourbon Cask Lightly Peated
Fergus tries Glasgow malt at Glasgow whisky festival, only to ask it to live up to the experience when he has it back home. He also makes some observations about openness and transparency, and the humility of cities.
Living Souls x Thompson Bros 3yo Blended Scotch
Ogilvie leads a four-way collab review of aβ¦collab. This time itβs the 3yo blended Scotch from Living Souls x Thomspon Bros: a sherry/peat blend and cracking value.
Torabhaig High Strength Duo
Admitting one of his favourite Scottish destinations, Charlie laments not having visited Torabhaig, yet. However, he travels vicariously through an official and an indy from Thompson Bros.
Benromach Contrasts High Enzyme
With Benromachβs latest Contrasts highlighting how high enzyme grain might affect the end product, Hamish considers how far whisky makers can push the envelope under todays regs.
Bunnahabhain Cruach MhΓ²na
Every once in a while a Dramface writer will lament the poor selection available in one of whiskyβs most potent retail spaces - GTR. Charlie uncovers a decent Bunnahabhain but he has an opinion.
Glasgow Oloroso 7yo Distillery Exclusive
After finally hooking up with some fellow Dramface pals in Glasgow, Ogilvie has to confess a feeling of giddiness. He cracks a Glasgow Distillery souvenir to help recall how great it was to render things real.
Cadenheadβs Tomatin 18yo
Ainsley had a forced whisky hiatus, but he rekindled his love for music while away. Over a tasty Cadenheadβs Tomatin 18yo, he realises keeping the passion might take a little thought and effort.
Teeling Chardonnay Cask
Sometimes, it neednβt be particularly complex, just good enough to nicely accompany a box set and an evening on the sofa. Hamish tees up a Teeling Chardonnay and wonders why itβs a first for Dramface.
Milroyβs Highland 19yo
Ally shares the concept of βbus dramsβ. This is a known practice and there are protocols and potential for social faux pas. But there are ways around it. Bring βinterestingβ drams. Like this 19yo Jura from Milroys.
Bunnahabhain 18yo
Staring at ever more sagging and creaking shelves, Drummond admits heβs been on something of a bottle ban in 2025. But it does allow him to crack some long saved charmers, like this Bunnahabhain 18yo.
Teaninich Duo
Having only heard of Teaninich, Charlie tracks down a bottle. Then a remarkable dram forces a bottle hunt. Before he knows it, Charlie finds himself quite happily in the Teaninich rabbit hole.
Thompson Bros Mystery Malt Series 3
That tricky third album. Itβs the third release of the Thompson Brothers Mystery Malt Series and Hamish grabs another unknown bottle. As does Dramface journeyman Jackie, for his debut!
Longmorn 12yo Signatory Vintage Cask Strength
Lamenting the disconnect between the whisky thatβs made and the whisky thatβs sold, Fergus discovers that - once more - itβs the indies that have our backs. A Signatory Vintage Longmorn is in the glass.