Whisky Reviews

Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.

Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.

Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop

Murray McDavid Duo

In a wonderfully candid and personal piece, Archie shares his transition into trusting independent bottlers and how he decided to start with Murray McDavid. It’s not what you might think.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Official vs Indy: Glenlossie

A stranger to Glenlossie until 2025, Charlie uncovered one of Diageo’s ‘blend houses’ in a Cadenhead’s tasting. Typically for him, a pleasant experience and a bottle purchase finds him exploring and comparing.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Ainsley Fife Scotch Whisky Ainsley Fife

Miltonduff 11yo 2006

Over time, Ainsley thinks the Scotch whisky landscape builds into a mental whisky bell-curve where favourites lie to one side and lesser malts the other. But what about the in-betweeners, such as this Cadenhead’s Miltonduff?

Read More
Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop

Seven from Tri Carragh

Facing an ever-expanding stash of samples, Archie decides to get torn into a pack of Tri Carragh samples he was sent last year, most of which are still available, and some of which are belters.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Hughie Cullen Scotch Whisky Hughie Cullen

Aultmore Duo

As a lapsed fan of Dungeons & Dragons, Hughie realises he’s using whisky as a way to continually re-write and relearn experiences. An independent duo of Aultmore illustrate a recent side-quest, and they’re tasty.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Wally Macaulay Scotch Whisky Wally Macaulay

The Cairn First Peek 3yo

Wally is surprised to see a release form The Cairn so soon. That it’s also only 1,000 bottles and only £50 for 57% ABV, he can’t help but pick it up. It makes him think about time, fairness and also Dramface.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop Scotch Whisky Archie Dunlop

Living Souls Trio

Even in far-flung California, Archie is landing decent indie bottlings. In a follow up to his Woodrows Foursome, we have a Living Souls Trio: Two Smoky Sevens and a Speyside, all crackers.

Read More