Whisky Reviews
Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.
Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.
AnCnoc 12yo Vintage Bottling
After a remarkable career, Ogilvie has decided to retire. Not from Dramface, but his real job. By pleasant coincidence he notes that the arrival and departure of his final chapter are marked by AnCnocβs 12 year old.
Not Another F*cking Whisky Book
A wee weekend bonus. Fletcher shares a recent βwhisky-themedβ book that resonated. A story of two decades serving the global whisky industry as a brand ambassador by Mitch Bechard
Decadent Drinks December 2025
Itβs Dougieβs turn to step up with a box of the latest outturn from Decadent Drinks. Like this weekend deep-dive read, itβs no small undertaking. But it starts with an Ardnamurchan, so heβs inβ¦
Thompson Bros Mystery Malt Series 3
Once more we visit the ultimate humbling - blind tasting whisky. This time around Ainsley considers what the minimal details are required to legally sell whisky with a Thompson Bros Mystery Malt Series 3.
AnCnoc 12yo
In revisiting an old favourite, Hughie puts the case forward for 40% ABV entry level offerings, as well as the dangers of applying the strategy to the rest of the range. AnCnoc 12 is in the glass.
Ledaig 1995 24yo Chapter 7
In a wonderfully warm and personal piece, Murdo shares what he was up to when this Chapter 7 Ledaig 1995 was distilled. For him it was a pivotal year and one that would set aspects of his life trajectory.
Hazelburn 10yo 2025 Release
Allyβs already decided heβs wonβt make any resolutions for 2026; last yearβs didnβt work out as planned. He found his deep dive into wine woefully restrictive. He makes up for it with a 10yo Hazelburn.
Ardnamurchan Heritage Barley 2025
Predicted to be a huge hoit, Ardnamurchan released their first small batch, larger outturn Golden Promise release. All from ex-bourbon barrels. Drummond heads a collaborative of four reviewers.
Dailuaine 11yo SMOS
Earie has given up worrying about the scale of his βcollectionβ and admitting that the fun is in buying more whisky. He trusts SMOS and buys blind, but he may have come a cropper on this Dailuaine.
Tomatin CΓΉ BΓ²can Creation #7
Hamish reflects on his 2025 whisky moments. Whilst settling on the Glasgow Whisky Festival as the highlight, he shares a CΓΉ BΓ²can Creation that surprised him, almost as much as the people he meets.
Bimber Bourbon Cask
Getting into the festive spirit, Charlie turns full-on whisky evangelist and makes advent calendars for pals. Starting with a few, it grows until heβs sharing 19! He includes this English Single Malt from Bimber.
Speyside Distillery 27yo
Ogilvie finds himself in a funk. His family notice it too. What else is there to do but crack a Thompson Bros Mystery Malt Series 3 and head to the back porch. Contemplative therapy time. Ogilvie style.
Glen Scotia 12yo Icon of Campbeltown No.3
In picking up the Glen Scotia Latest Icons release, Fletcher chooses to offer a shout-out to the faces behind the brands; those hard-working, tireless ambassadors that we all benefit from.
Auchentoshan 20yo Whisky Craft
Our resident Parisian Ainsley is still unpacking the madness that was Glasgowβs Whisky Festival in 2025. With some distance, he also unpacks a lesser seen indie Auchentoshan from newcomers Whisky Craft.
Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 8yo
In discovering a cracking SMWS Loch Lomond Inchmurrin, Broddy goes full Broddy and gives us a deep dive into our scoring, the whys and the whats and the hows. Itβs fascinating.
Glen Garioch 13yo Fragrant Drops
After Dougieβs whirlwind November, he finally has time to sit with his Fragrant Drops 13yo Glen Garioch. Since itβs rainy, he also uncorks his all-time Geery pinnacle bottle for a side-by-side.
Edradour 10yo 200th Anniversary
As a stickler for justice, Fletcher gives a shout out to the 200 years old Edradour. As he sips this new, all natural 10yo, he wonders what wouldβve happened if it hadnβt been saved.
Arran 18yo
Charlie has some agonising to do over his accumulated open bottles. He dives in to cull some off which, happily, brings this Arran 18yo to the fore, and he discovers itβs the first time weβve reviewed it.
Elevenses Linkwood 9yo
A solid and dependable dram is needed to help Mason come down after a whirlwind trip to Glasgow for the annual Whisky Festival. This Fragrant Drops Elevenses Linkwood does the trick nicely.
Living Souls Kildalton 19yo
Wally returns to ask why there are so many silly protectionist rules around stating where a whisky is made - and to whoβs detriment when itβs so. He does so over a rather lovely Living Souls 19yo βKildaltonβ.