Whisky Reviews

Here you'll find honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and the occasional disagreement, because no two palates are quite the same. We review widely, score reluctantly and remain convinced that whisky is far more interesting than the numbers attached to it.

Agreement is optional; curiosity is encouraged.

Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Glenrothes - Official vs Indy

In Charlie’s distillery deep-dives and comparisons, the indies have always won out. However, could a naturally coloured official Glenrothes turn that around? He tries two of them alongside two Cadenhead’s releases..

Read More
Scotch Whisky Ogilvie Shaw Scotch Whisky Ogilvie Shaw

Nc’Nean Huntress Duo

Ogilvie leads as he, Archie and Eallair team up on a duo of special releases from Nc’Nean. Supplied through Nick, each of them have a go at Edition 4 ‘ Lemon Meadow’ and 5 “Malted Teacake”.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Murdo McAtear Scotch Whisky Murdo McAtear

Tamdhu 15yo

It turns out Murdo is an anxious traveller. He reaches for a pre-flight dram - one that he hoped would be a nice replacement for his loved Glendronach 15yo. Did the Tamdhu 15yo do the trick?

Read More
Scotch Whisky Mason Mack Scotch Whisky Mason Mack

Glen Moray Classic

In railing against the addition of colour and chill-filtering, Mason is tripped up by a bargain-basement Glen Moray Classic. He’s forced to apply some pragmatism and just appreciate what it is.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Mason Mack Scotch Whisky Mason Mack

Eagle Rare 10yo

Mason has been ‘ enjoying’ his recent hiatus from alcohol. This year has been longer than most due to Europe’s ‘heat dome’ of 2026, which has had him reach for this Eagle Rare 10yo upon return.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Antique Blends Trio

Charlie picks up three blends from the past - his own past - and dips in to see what he was missing. A Chivas Regal 12yo from the 1970s alongside an old Johnnie Walker Swing and a 1980s Teachers.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell Scotch Whisky Charlie Campbell

Official vs Indy: Glenlossie

A stranger to Glenlossie until 2025, Charlie uncovered one of Diageo’s ‘blend houses’ in a Cadenhead’s tasting. Typically for him, a pleasant experience and a bottle purchase finds him exploring and comparing.

Read More
Scotch Whisky Murdo McAtear Scotch Whisky Murdo McAtear

Boann Marsala Cask

There aren’t many Irish whiskeys (or whiskies!) showing up in Murdo’s market, but he finds a Marsala Cask from Boann and pulls the trigger. Is it worth it? Is it any more transparent? Is it whisky or whiskey?

Read More
Scotch Whisky Fletcher Finlay Scotch Whisky Fletcher Finlay

Annandale Man O’Swords Fino Cask

After nearly smashing this bottle of Annandale before the photo shoot, Fletcher recalls the times he’s lost whiskies through packing fails and baggage handling fails. He also wants to know why this malt is such a positioning fail.

Read More