Glen Keith Distillery Edition

Official NAS Bottling | 40% ABV

Score: 4/10

Some promise.

TL;DR
Inoffensive and noses well, but falls apart from there

 

Whisky Recommendations eh?

Gifting and whisky is a bit of a conundrum. Either gifting or receiving, it can be an awkward interaction, especially when a reaction is anticipated upon opening, or it’s been recommended by ‘a whisky guy’.

I’m currently laying down, thankfully coming out of the back end of a cold/virus that has typically struck. It’s becoming all too common now that, post Glasgow Whisky Festival week, I end up with a lowered immune system and some kind of head cold. There’s only so much Berocca and painkillers one can consume before pivoting to a hot toddy in the hope it’ll soothe the pains and help with sleep.

The cupboard in the kitchen would typically house some of the whiskies for a hot toddy: Jameson, Bushmills, Famous Grouse and the odd Laphroaig 10yo might sleep in there, only to be looked at when it’s cold/flu season, or when I’m too lazy to go upstairs to pick something a bit more interesting.

This whisky nook has been a bit slim of late and mostly holds whatever wine might be on hand for a small glass or chucking into a bolognese. But this week I spotted a box, which is odd because I normally chuck out any packaging that comes with whisky to save on any precious shelving space.

It’s a Glen Keith Distillery Edition, a bottle I’d honestly forgotten I even had and probably hid in the back on purpose. I was reminded it was a birthday present given to me earlier this year from my in-laws, and I do recall my father-in-law ranting about this bottle multiple times over the past few years, stating how nice it was when he picked it up at the local Tesco. That’s probably why it’s been punted to the back of the cupboard (sorry Frankie).

Grabbing it for said hot toddy, a thought came to mind to give this a bit more attention to see how it actually fares, rather than base it upon my whisky-geek assumptions. It would only be fair, as then I could have a genuine conversation with my father-in-law on this particular expression. Plus, it might surprise me. I might even like it.

The bottle itself got me thinking about receiving whisky gifts - or purchasing whisky as a gift for someone - I don’t think I like it. Bear with me while I explain why, maybe I’m just bad at recommendations, but you can be the judge. 

In the workplace, more often than not, I’ll be asked my opinion when it comes to buying someone a whisky gift. The follow up questions from me result in many eye rolls and looks of, ‘sorry I asked’. But it’s hard to pinpoint the right bottle for that person without knowing some important facts. 

I always start with, ‘What’s your budget?’ which normally helps me narrow down what level we’re talking about here. ‘What do they normally drink?’ or ‘Do you know if they prefer something on the smoky/peaty side or a whisky that’s fruit & sweet?’ You know the questions, trying your hardest to get the best answers without dazzling them with options of whisky regions, high strength and even cask varieties. 

Unsurprisingly you can guess that the direction would be to salvage whatever options are available on Bezos marketplace or the local supermarket for £25-30, which sadly isn’t a lot. Then you’re left hoping that the selected bottle lands well with the recipient, and not, “well the whisky guy at work recommended it, so blame him if it’s not up your street!”. For the jury, that’s exhibit A.

Exhibit B, picking whisky for family members who also like a tipple now and then and would have the odd bottle of Powers or Bells floating about the house or a bottle of today’s review on hand as well. I always try to bring a bottle of something tasty and engaging for everyone to enjoy particularly around the Christmas holidays.

Previous bottles have been Cotswolds English Single Malt, Tomatin 14yo and Loch Lomond 12yo. I even brought a Lagavulin 16yo once but it didn’t go down too well. Once it was a Thompson Bros TB/BSW and it did slightly better. But overall, I’m a whisky geek and the gulf in priorities I have compared to most can almost make me seem like a whisky fraud. 

I’m thinking part of the problem is glassware. When we’re all sitting down for a dram, large tumblers are the only thing on offer, and the most prevalent comment has been, ‘oh she’s a bit sharp’. Perhaps it’s that, maybe the higher ABV from 40% to the 46% of my geek-pleasing pour is a step too far, but again there’s a red-faced moment when you’re “the whisky one” in the family, and the recommendations fall short of expectations. Or, I’m just shit at recommending whiskies.

IF this bottle proves any way enjoyable and palatable, then it’s the one getting purchased for sharing with the masses when a night cap is called for. So here’s hoping this doesn’t fall flat on its face like I’ve continually found to date.

 

 

Review

Glen Keith Distillery Edition, NAS (No Age Statement) Official Bottling, 40% ABV
£24-30 and often discounted, wide availability

This is only the second Glen Keith reviewed here on Dramface. The first being a Decadent Drinks bottle reviewed by Dallas way back in the early days. So I’ll cover Glen Keith a bit more here before today's review.

The distillery was mothballed in 1999, before undergoing major refurbishment in 2012/2013 and reopening in June 2013. Most of Glen Keith’s production is pumped into Chivas blends, with most of the single malt bottlings being pre-mothball vintage releases. The distillery itself sits right beside its sister - Strathisla Distillery, another distillery under the Chivas umbrella. 

From what I can read online, it uses long lyne arms and adopts a fermentation time of around 55 hours. While it was the first ever Scotch distillery to introduce gas fired stills in the 1970’s, it seems to have adopted steam driven stills since the refurb. Interestingly, also back in the early 1970s, it once produced peated liquid under two different names: ‘Glenisla’ and ‘Craigduff’ - worth keeping an eye out after tasting this to see how the liquid might have fared as a peated option. 

Let’s have a sniff and sip of today's modern manifestation.

 

Score: 4/10

Some promise.

TL;DR
Inoffensive and noses well, but falls apart from there

 

Nose

Soft. Fruity. Hints of toffee and malt. Some green apples and pineapple cubes. Hints of honey mixed in with cloves and spice. I’m getting nutmeg and some cinnamon. There’s a floral element but you’ve really gotta hunt for it beyond the fruit sweetness. It finishes off with some kiwi and boiled sweets.

 

Palate

The initial sip had no easily identifiable and definable taste or note to distinguish. And that’s it swirling about my mouth for about fifteen to twenty seconds. It’s thin. Eventually it tastes of burnt sugar and bitterness like from a square of dark chocolate. I go in for some more and it’s a bit more prickly, but it doesn’t remind me of your typical Speysider: I’m left wanting more. 

There’s very little in the way of orchard fruits and honey compared to what was on the nose. More sour elements are here with the odd blast of coffee, dark chocolate again and perhaps some of that green apple from before.

The thin mouthfeel results in a short-to-medium finish, where the sour notes amplify as everything else fades.

 

The Dregs

The nose on this whisky is far better than the palate. It’s disappointing because after nosing I thought I was onto a winner here, a hidden gem from the supermarket shelves. But, no.

Overall it’s inoffensive and a fairly easy sipper. One to pour when you really don’t need to think or decipher what’s in the glass. But generally it lacks complexity, layers, or any grip to make you go back for any more than a dram or two.

Annoyingly, it’s not what I’d hoped. I thought my father-in-law might be onto a winner here, but I can’t hold it against him, especially if this is a bottle he really enjoys. It makes my gifting to him that little bit easier and at least I know what drams to expect anytime we share a night cap. 

It’s your typical supermarket whisky. Often on offer and just that level below that we would expect in terms of grip, complexity and experience. There’s a time and place for whiskies like this. For me, it’ll be for the hot toddies and summer highballs. 

In terms of my own whisky gifting, this won’t be on the list of recommendations, but at least narrowing those options helps and doesn’t out me as a whisky fraud. Yet.

 

Score: 4/10

 

Tried this? Share your thoughts in the comments below. HF

 

What are your own personal top distilleries?

At the point of this article’s publication, Glen Keith doesn’t currently appear in the Dramface Top 40.

You can influence that vote here!

 

Other opinions on this:

The Whiskey Novice

Words of Whisky

Whiskybase

Got a link to a reliable review? Tell us.

Hamish Frasier

Originally hailing from Ireland and enjoying the available Irish whiskeys, Hamish was drawn into the world of Scotch malt and further afield while he fell into the flavour chase rabbit-hole. Driven by the variation in whisky and bitten by ‘the bug’ he was unable to resist taking his incessant geeking-out to friends and family. Now they may enjoy a break as he uses the written word to bring that enthusiasm onto a wider audience. He’s in good company. We all know how that feels Hamish. Geek away fella, geek away.

Next
Next

Full Case of Mystery Malts Series 5