Core release | 46% ABV
Score: 6/10
Good stuff.
TL;DR
Solid offering and much to like, just missing that final ‘zing’
For the sake of Revelance*
*Not a typo
This platform should not exist.
Whilst that seems an absurd statement or - depending on where the emphasis is placed - a call to end the site, this platform is an odd construction, especially when considered objectively.
But think about it, Dramfacers - as we’ve come to call each other - do not get paid for their contributions. Instead, with very few exceptions, we purchase the bottles we review. The outcome of this is threefold: the drams reviewed appealed (in some manner) to the writer, the drams reviewed are therefore likely to appeal to those reading, for often similar reasons and the reviews can be trusted as considered, honest, independent, and approached from an angle that hopefully resonates with our readership.
But when viewed as a contributor, it’s plain daft.
We buy bottles, spend a good deal of time considering their existence and contents – often within the pre-tasting ramble – and then put pen to paper in a measured manner before unleashing into the great electrostatic wilderness. Bonkers, right? It really shouldn’t exist.
I used to write music and book reviews. Honestly, getting both mediums sent to me for free to consider and write about was (almost) never a chore. Granted, some of the genres of music were not my cup of tea, and some of the books were poorly written and/or devoid of a page-turning narrative. But, having mastered a few skills in preparation (i.e. skimming and scanning) and others with regard to prose, it was a role I greatly enjoyed. And that is why Dramface does exist – the joy of the review.
The exploration, deliberation and disclosure of a review can, perhaps, be called ‘Revelance’ for the contributor. That’s not a typo.
Anyone who writes does so in the belief that what they put forward has some sort of relevance – otherwise, why bother? Whatever the tale, quip, fable, or memory, it is shared in the belief that someone out there will find something relatable, extraordinary, or interesting in it: something relevant.
But beyond that, the author revels in the publication. Granted, there is trepidation, but because Dramface is free for anyone to read, each writer openly reveals something about themselves with each piece, fuelled by the joy of having a moment to share.
Personally, I find the writing cathartic – often as an aside from in-depth research and writing that I may otherwise be engaged in, or simply as a vessel for venting an issue, concern, observation or just anything that pops into my head.
But I write because of a need for ‘Revelance’ – the mix of the pleasure derived from seeing work published and the desire to be considered, and remain, relevant. I can’t consider myself a neologist, nor have I researched whether anyone else has ever made the connection between the two words, but I feel - in today’s context - the definition of my made-up word conveys what we Dramfacers get out of these pieces.
So back to my early point. Dramface should not exist. Commercially, it makes no sense. When I was professionally writing my music and book reviews, the physical copies of each were sent to me, and I was being paid to write the review. Although this was by the magazine publisher, not the music and book publishers (and I should add that I spent a number of years being paid to review whiskies too).
This is much easier to achieve when wholesale costs of CDs and books are about £5 each and much less so when the tax alone on a bottle of whisky is twice that and shipping is also considerably higher.
As an aside, I really enjoy a wine vlogger called Tom Gilbey. Clearly an expert on the subject, Tom can assess and express impressions on as many as a dozen wines in an entertaining half-hour video. Each video I watch, I wish that this were possible in the whisky world, but financially it would be crippling.
A dozen wines for Tom might cost £120 (often less) – this budget could be swallowed up by a single bottle of single malt Scotch (or other whisky varieties). A tasting of twelve, even with bargain-basement single-malt bottlings, is unachievable for less than £300. And let’s be honest, that would become dull quite quickly for viewers.
Even if, and I’ll use the first person for this, I were to set up a similar channel to Tom’s and invite companies to donate bottles, the traction would be Very limited (capital V on purpose). “Dear producer, I would like a bottle of your £50+ whisky for a video I am making where your whisky will go up against eleven other whiskies, and I’ll state whether it is class, pass, or arse, having spent approximately 30 seconds drinking it. Please send full bottles to…”
Yeah, good luck with that one.
Short of me winning the EuroMillions lottery, that business plan would struggle – and really, that’s the point. Tom’s channel is so entertaining because, in the wine world of unfathomable choice, Tom is able to be truly independent, calling established names out loud as being ‘arse’ and, conversely, wines from bargain supermarkets as being ‘class’. You might, in the hopes of replicating that in the whisky world, get the first offering from a company for a video, but then how do you publicly call it ‘arse’ if you’re expecting follow-up bottles from the same rep? Again, good luck with that.
Dramface is here to do just that. In fact, it’s why we all write under pen names. We are free to unleash our full feelings; uncoloured and un-chillfiltered. This term is already taken (and again, I’m too lazy to seek out where), but we are the ‘cask-strength edition’ of whisky reviews. We neither rely on freebies nor ask for them – but if sent, we do - on occasion - use them, and we judge them fairly, independently and with as much consideration as we can. We are slightly more forgiving and nuanced than Class, Pass or Arse, but we aren’t trying to be visually entertaining (much tougher in my opinion) or create soundbites.
Anyway, this is a long way of self-congratulating the site for existing and trying to remain an independent, considered voice within the ever-growing plethora of opinions, reviews, soundbites, and white noise swimming around the ocean of information out there.
We shall crack on, seeking further Revelance.
Review
Isle of Harris Single Malt, Highland Scotch whisky, official core release, 46% ABV
£43- 50 and wide availability
I’m reliably informed that this release contains some of the oldest maturing Harris single malt. That would mean casks from either late 2015 or early 2016. Granted, for some this will never equal “old”, but in a world with so many new-ish distilleries, it means 10-year-old stock (give or take a few months) in a non-age statement bottling.
I first tried this at the Whisky Fringe in Edinburgh, immediately bought a bottle and then let it sit, waiting for a preamble. Now seems the ideal time to crack open and review.
The colour makes it clear that ex-Sherry casks won't mask any youth. Nor can Harris boast lashings of peat to also help smooth out any juvenile spots. This is, arguably, the truest expression of Harris yet – ‘truest’ isn’t really the word I’m looking for. Natural, or naked – again, not quite what I want. What I mean is, this whisky should give us a really good ‘under the hood’ moment with regard to Harris spirit.
Score: 6/10
Good stuff.
TL;DR
Solid offering and much to like, just missing that final ‘zing’
Nose
Well, first of all, there is some smoke. It is light, slightly buttery and with a clear cereal note throughout. Diving in again, the cereal note sits on top – imagine a dog sniffing toast that has fallen marmalade side down. The toasted grain note is first, followed by a slight bready note, butter and then the marmalade. That is what I’m getting on the nose. With air, the butteriness gets stronger, and a heathery note comes in at the sides. Just the stingiest of hints of fruit are trying their best to emerge under the toast blanket.
Palate
Again, just a wisp of smoke at first, followed by a toasted note. As the spirit coats the palate, the peat gathers strength, but it never leans towards an overly maritime feel. It is soft and malty, eminently drinkable and likeable. Rather than a full-on hug, this is an arm across the shoulders with a gentle squeeze. I’m missing the toast of the nose and the big hope of the marmalade note to spring forward with its zesty fruitiness.
The Dregs
It is so easy to love all that is Isle of Harris Scotch whisky, and I am 100% sure anyone buying this will happily watch the bottle slowly empty with each dram. I am also sure that there will be some great bottlings to watch out for in the future.
While I heard a rumour that Harris is currently trying to peddle a ‘limited edition’ rye cask variant for £150 RRP, I feel it cannot be true. Surely somebody, somewhere in the Isle of Harris orbit has the sense to see that would not be reading the room. Anyway, that’s purely anecdotal. In my experience, thus far, each and every bottle of Harris we buy has been worthwhile and, let’s be honest, the price has been great.
It keeps the stills hot and the casks full with this incredible and remote endeavour.
Score: 6/10
Tried this? Share your thoughts in the comments below. FF
-
Dramface is free.
Its fierce independence and community-focused content is funded by that same community. We don’t do ads, sponsorships or paid-for content. If you like what we do you can support us by becoming a Dramface member for the price of a magazine.
However, if you’ve found a particular article valuable, you also have the option to make a direct donation to the writer, here: buy me a dram - you’d make their day. Thank you.
For more on Dramface and our funding read our about page here.
What are your own personal top distilleries?
At the point of this article’s publication, Isle of Harris does not currently feature in the Dramface Top 40.
You can influence that vote here!